The university's defining tension is captured in the line:
“Stanford shouldn’t be the Navy; it should be the Pirates.”This phrase represents the struggle between order and openness, procedure and disruption, safety and courage.
The Pirates have been dealt a symbolic blow with the loss of their home, the lake, which led to a decline in piracy. The draining of the lake and the COVID pandemic further accelerated this decline, with the Navy's increasing dominance stripping the Band's independence and shuttering Greek life and theme houses.
The alumni fondly remember these last safe havens of piracy, which are now lost. The university's shift towards the Navy's values has tamed the pirate spirit.
Author's summary: Stanford lost its pirate spirit.